2006 Tony Awards
Best Musical Best
Performance by an Actor in a Musical - John Lloyd Young
Best Featured Actor in a Musical - Christian Hoff
Best Lighting Design of a Musical - Howell Binkley

Grammy Award
Best Show Album

2006 Outer Critics Circle 2005-2006 Awards
Outstanding Broadway Musical

2006 Drama League Awards
Distinguished Production of a Musical

2008 Tony Award
Best Play

2008 Pulitzer Prize
Drama

2008 Drama Desk Awards
Best New Play

2008 League Award
Distinguished Production of a Play

2008 New York Drama Critics' Circle Award
Best Play

2008 Outer Critics Award
Distinguished Production of a Play

2008 Drama League Award
Distinguished Production of a Musical

Tony Awards
Best Actress in a Musical (nominated)
Best Actor in a Musical (nominated)
Best Orchestrations (nominated)

Tony Awards
Best Musical (nominated)
Best Book of a Musical (nominated)
Best Original Score (nominated)
Best Actor in a Musical (Stephen Lynch, nominee)
Best Choreography (nominated)